Website founded by Milan Velimirović in 2006
10:22 UTC
| |
MatPlus.Net Forum Promenade A nice problem by Reddmann |
|
|
|
You can only view this page!
| | (1) Posted by Jacques Rotenberg [Thursday, May 17, 2007 20:03] | A nice problem by Reddmann I found quite nice the following problem :
H. Reddmann
Die Schwalbe 1987
(= 8+3 )
2#
1.Bc3? [2.0-0-0‡] Rg8!
1.Bc4? [2.0-0-0‡] Rf8!
1.Sc4? [2.0-0-0‡] Re8+!
1.Sc5? [2.0-0-0‡] Rd8!
1.Rc2! [2.0-0-0‡]
with castling and bicolor bi-valves
Some suggestions might be :
Sd3->Sd6 may be better , 3 tries are on a same square (c4), and it introduces new tries :
1.Kf1? [2.Bd5‡]
1…Rf8 2.Q×c6‡
mais 1…Re8!
1.S×c8? mais 1…Kg1! (a bit formal)
another transformation further : Qa8->Qb7 :
1.Bd5+? Kg1! (2.Qg7‡?? gives one more use to the Bishop g7)
another transformation further :+ black Pa2 :
1.Rf2?, 1.Re2? mais 1…Kg1! unpins the Rook c6!
so I propose the new version : Sd3->Sd6, Qa8->Qb7, +blackPa2
what does the author think of it ? | | (2) Posted by Hauke Reddmann [Friday, May 18, 2007 14:55] | Hmmm. Difficult. 20 years ago I gave not much thought to
such details. My biggest "but" is that I think unthematic
tries only distract, and when it even introduces an
otherwise unneccessary pawn into an aristocratic problem...
I put the S to d3 so that he stands directly besides his
colleague, like the wB, wR and (cum grano salis) bR.
Hauke
| | (3) Posted by Jacques Rotenberg [Sunday, May 20, 2007 01:59] | I think that I understood what you say when I saw the problem...
I agree that the most controversial proposal of the three is the adding of the pawn. | | (4) Posted by Jacques Rotenberg [Tuesday, May 22, 2007 09:41] | However Hauke,
You could reply also
1) The Knight is more natural on d3, closer to the black King. It gives taste to the pseudo-try 1.Rg2??
2) The fact that all the squares between c6 and c1 are used as interference places is also a nice pattern
3) The fact that the Queen is left "en prise", and in the corner gives a preference to a8 and not to b7 | | No more posts |
MatPlus.Net Forum Promenade A nice problem by Reddmann |
|
|
|