|(1) Posted by Juraj Lörinc [Monday, Oct 10, 2011 21:23]|
Belokon 60 JT results
In the Russian internet the award of the JT of Ukrainian was just published:
In my opinion some of the awarded problems are nowadays hardly publishable, but the jubilee was satisfied enough to give 13 prizes, 15 honourable mentions and 19 commendations. The comment on this was as follows (translation by Google Translate & me):
"Принимая во внимание техническую сложность составления многоходовых задач кооперативного жанра с идеальными матами, тем более с двумя решениями, юбиляр посчитал целесообразным отметить все корректные задачи."
"Taking into account the technical difficulties of composing the multi-solution helpmate moremovers with ideal mates, especially with two solutions, the jubilee found it appropriate to award all the correct problems."
Judge for yourself.
|(2) Posted by Michael McDowell [Monday, Oct 10, 2011 23:20]|
I can’t help thinking of Tony Miles’s famous review of Schiller’s “Unorthodox chess openings”….
|(3) Posted by Dan Meinking [Tuesday, Oct 11, 2011 02:48]; edited by Dan Meinking [11-10-11]|
The 1st Prize has S mates on 3 consecutive squares, but beyond that it's hard to distinguish it from...
... which has the identical force in 3-solution form.
The 2nd Prize author, Karamaniz, has published a number of multi-line wB-minimal h#7's...
... although the nuances of this one seem distinct enough.
|(4) Posted by Juraj Lörinc [Tuesday, Oct 11, 2011 09:51]; edited by Juraj Lörinc [11-10-11]|
From the Bohemian school point of view exact echo repetition of mating position has some additional merit, so that I would not write the 1st Prize totally off.
Added later: ... based on the comparison with h# of Marcel Tribowski. There is still possibility of someone else doing it earlier.
|(5) Posted by Dan Meinking [Wednesday, Oct 12, 2011 06:03]|
@Juraj: Yes, the exact-echoes are merit-worthy, but deeming them prize-worthy is a matter of taste.
|(6) Posted by Juraj Lörinc [Wednesday, Oct 12, 2011 12:14]|
I totally agree with the previous statement. :)
No more posts
MatPlus.Net Forum Competitions Belokon 60 JT results